Skip to content 
Real estate investors typically prioritize rental income and property taxes, often overlooking home insurance. Some assume it’s a fixed cost across the country and don’t pay much attention to it. However, neglecting home insurance could be a costly mistake.
Insurance.com states that the average annual cost of home insurance nationwide is approximately $2,800. This breaks down to around $231 per month for $300,000 in dwelling coverage and liability with a $1,000 deductible. However, these figures vary by location. It’s crucial for real estate investors to recognize that these numbers are for owner-occupied homeowners insurance; landlords should anticipate adding an extra 25%.
Not surprisingly, states with higher risks of natural disasters such as hail, storms, tornadoes, and flooding tend to have the highest insurance rates. According to data from insurance.com, the top five most expensive states for home insurance, where average rates range from $4,142 to $5,317 per year, are:
- Kansas
- Oklahoma
- Arkansas
- Nebraska
- Texas
The data from insurance.com shows that the five states with the lowest home insurance rates, where rates range from $582 to $1,551, are:
- Hawaii
- Washington, D.C.
- New Hampshire
- California
- Vermont
One particularly surprising state on the list of low insurance rates is Hawaii. However, it’s important not to be misled. Hawaii’s affordability is largely due to the exclusion of hurricane damage from its coverage. This underscores the crucial importance for landlords to carefully read the fine print of their insurance policies to understand what is and isn’t covered.
While weather remains the primary factor influencing insurance rates, several other considerations play a role. These include population density proximity to potential risk areas like woodlands (for wildfires), rivers, and busy roads. Conversely, proximity to fire hydrants and fire departments can also impact rates positively. Additionally, the historical risk for claims in your area is another factor that insurers take into account when determining insurance premiums.
Ways for Landlords to Reduce Insurance Expenses
Landlords can take several steps to minimize the necessary cost of insuring their properties, including:
Maintain Your Property in Optimal Condition
Regular maintenance is essential for identifying and addressing issues such as cracks, leaks, faulty smoke alarms, mold, and infestations at an early stage. Additionally, ensure that your property includes the following features:
- Well-lit hallways
- Closed fire doors
- Clean walkways
- A strong roof & foundation
- Functional fire escapes
Increase your deductible amount
Increasing your deductible, which is the amount you’re responsible for paying before your insurance coverage begins, can lower your landlord’s insurance premium costs and discourage frivolous claims. By saving money on your premium, you can allocate those funds towards purchasing additional insurance coverage for other potential claims.
Emphasize safety
The insurance company rewards landlords who prioritize safety.
- Interior & exterior lighting
- Security cameras
- Alarm systems
- Connected smart security devices
- Smoke & CO2 detectors
Upgrade Your Property’s Core Systems
Insurance claims often stem from issues with main electrical, plumbing, and heating systems. To secure better pricing upon policy renewal, ensure these systems undergo regular checks and upgrades to modern standards. Provide insurers with comprehensive information for verification.
Opt for a Master Landlord Policy.
Consolidating all your properties under a single policy offers better premium rates, especially for a sizable portfolio. Opting for a master landlord insurance policy streamlines paperwork and reduces the need to monitor multiple individual policies.
Shop around
Insurance quotes can vary significantly, so it’s crucial to invest time in shopping around. Explore online options, consult fellow local landlords to inquire about preferred companies or brokers, and gather multiple quotes for comparison.
Types of Insurance Coverage for Landlords
As a landlord, key considerations for your insurance policy include:
- Rental property insurance: Landlords typically opt for rental property insurance, which combines liability, hazard, and loss of income coverage into a single policy.
- Flood insurance: Living in a designated flood zone entails additional expenses that you can’t afford to overlook. In essence, it’s wise to avoid purchasing property in flood-prone areas altogether.
- Income Coverage Loss: Loss of rent insurance provides coverage for lost rental income if your apartment becomes uninhabitable due to a natural disaster. While some landlord policies include this coverage as standard, it’s optional for others. It’s essential to note that loss of rent insurance doesn’t extend to cover a tenant’s inability to pay rent due to illness or other reasons. When considering a landlord insurance policy, anticipate paying approximately one-third to one-half of the total premium for this coverage. Therefore, it’s crucial to factor this expense carefully into your overall calculations.
- Sewer & water line backup: While some utility or water companies may propose adding this coverage to your monthly bill, it’s prudent to have it explicitly included in your insurance policy. The repair costs for a ruptured main water or sewer line can escalate to tens of thousands of dollars, making comprehensive coverage essential.
- Tenant rent default insurance: Investing in rent guarantee insurance can offer peace of mind and help you sleep better at night if you can afford it. Also referred to as rent guarantee insurance, this coverage safeguards landlords against tenants who fail to pay rent, ensuring steady cash flow and reducing stress levels.
- Pet insurance: Pet-friendly rental properties are highly sought after, so offering this option can enhance your competitiveness as a landlord. However, it’s crucial to protect yourself in case a tenant’s pet causes harm or damages your property. One approach is to require tenants to have pet coverage included in their renter’s insurance policy. Yet, it’s essential to recognize that landlord-tenant laws vary from state to state, so you’ll need to determine the most cost-effective way to safeguard yourself when pets are present in your building.
- Umbrella insurance: Many landlords prioritize their bottom-line cash flow, often overlooking the importance of umbrella insurance. However, if your margins allow for it, umbrella insurance can be invaluable. It serves as secondary coverage to protect you once the limits on your standard liability policy have been surpassed. This extra layer of protection can be particularly beneficial in scenarios involving lawsuits, medical expenses, and lost wages.
Final Thoughts
Being a landlord comes with inherent risks, as you’re subject to the unpredictable forces of weather and human behavior—both notoriously unreliable. To safeguard your profitability, it’s essential to remain vigilant against potential pitfalls that could drain your finances. This means accounting for worst-case scenarios and selecting the appropriate insurance policies to protect your investments.
As you expand your real estate portfolio, adjusting your insurance coverage becomes imperative. Time plays a crucial role in real estate, leveling the playing field for investors. Holding onto your assets over time typically leads to increased profits. Therefore, if allocating a bit more toward insurance affects your short-term cash flow, it’s prudent to consider it. This ensures you can weather unforeseen challenges and ultimately bolster your profits in the long term.
