Skip to content 
The U.S. real estate market seems unstoppable as home prices across the country continue to rise. According to the recent report from analytics company CoreLogic, there was an impressive year-over-year growth of 5.2% in November 2023.
This trend is not a one-time occurrence. In October 2023, home prices saw a substantial 4.7% year-over-year increase. CoreLogic’s outlook indicates a consistent growth pattern in home prices throughout 2024, with a projected 2.5% year-over-year increase expected in November 2024 compared to November 2023.
The major challenge currently confronting the Detroit real estate market is affordability, and it’s on a downward trend. According to Redfin, affordability reached its lowest point in 2023, with only 16% of all homes for sale in the U.S. considered affordable for the typical buyer. Despite this challenging scenario, the question arises: why are prices continuing to rise?
What Factors Contribute to the Continuous Rise in Prices?
Several interrelated factors contribute to this situation. Firstly, there’s the well-known surge in mortgage rates, which has constrained buyers’ budgets, turning housing that was once within reach into something many can no longer afford.
While mortgage rates started to decrease in late 2023, dropping from their peak of over 8% to just under 7% as of November, this reduction hasn’t been sufficient to render homeownership affordable in areas that were already largely unaffordable for the majority of their residents.
Dr. Selma Hepp, Chief Economist for CoreLogic, noted in the report that “in some metro areas, such as those in the Mountain West and the Northwest, higher interest rates are having a greater impact on homebuyers’ budgets, which is contributing to a larger seasonal slump.” The report highlights that Idaho (-1.3%), Utah (-0.4%), and Washington, D.C. (-0.2%) all witnessed annual decreases in house prices.
Conversely, regions that maintain “relative affordability” for buyers, coupled with reduced inventory, saw significant increases in home prices. In the Northeast markets, Connecticut (10.6%), Rhode Island (11.6%), and New Jersey (10.5%) all experienced substantial double-digit gains. Dr. Selma Hepp commented, “Markets where the prolonged inventory shortage has been exacerbated by the lack of new homes for sale recorded notable price gains over the course of 2023.”
Essentially, residents in these regions can still afford homes despite rising interest rates because local wages are sufficiently high to cover mortgage costs. As the demand for these relatively affordable areas increases, home prices also rise accordingly.
The Rise of Detroit
In cities, the situation takes a different turn. Certain metro areas exhibited unexpected surges in home prices that didn’t align with the overall growth pace in their neighboring regions.
Detroit, in particular, stood out as an unexpected frontrunner, registering the highest year-over-year home price growth among the metro areas analyzed in the report and surpassing Miami for the first time in 16 months. Dr. Selma Hepp explained to CNBC that Detroit, with an appreciation of 8.7% as of November 2023, was catching up after trailing in home price growth during the pandemic. However, there’s more to the story than just this catch-up phase.
Detroit has transformed into a metro area, gaining popularity as an affordable destination for higher-tier housing. Overcoming its previous reputation as a city in decline, Detroit is now attracting individuals with larger budgets because their money can stretch a bit further in the city. The historic neighborhoods in Detroit offer attractive housing options that, while expensive for the area, are considered well-priced for the available features and quality.
From a technical standpoint, Detroit is categorized as one of the overvalued metro markets in the report. This implies that home prices in Detroit are relatively high compared to local wages. This situation is not unique to Detroit, as approximately 82% of the 397 metro areas analyzed in the report are also considered overvalued. Dr. Selma Hepp explained to CNBC, “It really depends on who is buying in the area, and we’ve seen more higher-income folks buying in those areas.”
In addition to Detroit, several other major cities experienced significant jumps in home prices. These include Miami with an 8.3% increase, San Diego with a 7.7% rise, and Chicago with a 6.5% uptick.
Real estate investors venturing into a city like Detroit must be discerning in their property choices. The higher-income individuals identified by CoreLogic seek properties that are above average and provide value for their money. So, while the challenge of affordability persists, it takes on a slightly different nuance in a sizable metro area where discerning buyers are looking for quality and value in their investments.
For urban investors, it’s advisable to seek homes that go beyond being simply inexpensive. Concentrate on properties with the potential to stand out significantly after a renovation. Conversely, if you’re investing outside a major city, prioritizing value for money becomes crucial, so aim to provide buyers with the most competitive price first and foremost.
Florida’s Real Estate Market Might be Entering a Downturn
If you’re concerned about housing markets to steer clear of, the CoreLogic report issues cautionary forecasts about four Florida markets. These include:
- Palm Bay-Melbourne-Titusville
- West Palm Beach-Boca Raton-Delray Beach
- Tampa-St. Petersburg-Clearwater
- Deltona-Daytona Beach-Ormond Beach
All of these markets have a “very high” probability, exceeding 70%, of experiencing a decline in home prices over the next twelve months, according to the CoreLogic report.
A brief examination of local data in these areas and a comparison make it apparent why they may be heading for home price declines. For instance, let’s consider the Palm Bay area, which has a median home price of $345,000, an average salary of $49,356, and an unemployment rate of 3.2%. In contrast, Miami, currently undergoing a housing boom, has a median home price of $699,000, an average salary of $60,900, and an unemployment rate of 1.3%—showing a steady decrease since June 2023.
Miami is recognized as one of the overvalued markets, as indicated by the CoreLogic report. The average home prices in Miami exceed what the local population can afford. However, the dynamics reveal that despite being technically more affordable, areas like Palm Bay are less attractive to buyers who may face challenges in finding employment. Miami is drawing in both wealthier buyers seeking quality homes in a warm city and in-state movers looking for improved employment opportunities.
Real estate investors in Florida should pay close attention to these trends. It doesn’t necessarily imply that buying only in Miami is the solution, but investing in at-risk areas will demand a different approach — one that prioritizes understanding the financial capacities of local buyers in those areas.
